The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable

Nassim Nicholas Taleb (essayist and mathematical trader) writes in a sometimes stilted and perhaps condescending fashion – but his book is entertaining, and for the most part interesting. He truly rakes over the coals the experts on Wall Street who make predictions based on historical data (perhaps this could include the buying and selling of mortgage backed securities?) because they use trends, and ignore the improbable.

His outlook is to first acknowledge the black swan; and then employ it, to his advantage. His belief is that we neither make huge gains nor have huge losses through the historical, only through the improbable, or unthinkable.

The name “The Black Swan . . .” is taken from the fact that for years the world knew there were NO black swans; using the metaphor “black swan” meant nonexistent. Then Black Swans were discovered in Australia.

Taleb’s black swan is ” . . . a large-impact, hard-to-predict, and rare event beyond the realm of normal expectations.” September 11, 2001 is referred to as a “black swan”.

Real Estate investors know that now is the perfect time to buy real estate with the foreclosure market being what it is, but it is a dreadful time to get a loan for real estate. As a large-impact, unpredicted and rare event, it seems to qualify as a black swan. So, if we acknowledge it, how to use it?

Borrowers are certainly being given every opportunity to get refinanced on loans in default in ways that no one would have ever thought possible – the FHA Secure program will allow a refinance to people ONLY IN DEFAULT and allow them to keep the second mortgage they have now. Lenders are developing programs that will allow a cltv of 125%; refinancing what was an 80% first mortgage up to 100% value and allowing the second to stay, increasing the loan to 120% of the value of the property. I wouldn’t want to owe 25% more than my house was worth, but it beats foreclosure.

For real estate investors (and I’m not recommending speculation here . . . take note) there are properties that were manipulated by developers and builders that could present a powerful black swan advantage in the price they’re getting now, and the equity they afford. I’ve seen condos in Atlanta that were listed for $1,000,000 sell for $250,000 in bank sales in the last month. They’re a bargain at $250K even if the market takes a couple of years to recover.

This is the time to think outside the box – and stay on the lookout for the black swan.

More on FHA Secure

While the FHA Secure program is going to help people in default because their arms reset, I wonder about those people who took a second job, or a second and third job, and are eating cornbread and beans in order to make their mortgage payments rather than let them go into default . . . When is someone going to let them refinance for some relief? More on the FHA Secure program: “It’s not the government’s job to bail out speculators or those who made the decision to buy a home they knew they could never afford,” said President Bush. “Yet there are many American homeowners who could get through this difficult time with a little flexibility from their lenders or a little help from their government.” Homeowners must have 3% equity in their home and demonstrate that the original loan was being paid on a timely basis until it reset in order to qualify under the FHA Secure Program. Previously, the FHA would not guarantee refinances on loans with delinquencies. The loan must be within standard FHA loan limit guidelines, but the administration apparently supports legislation to raise the limits. The FHA plan is to charge slightly higher mortgage insurance premiums to address the additional risk The FHA estimates that 500,000 of 2+ million arms set to adjust could go into foreclosure. Even with the 80,000 borrowers the FHA will bail out, it still estimates it will only assist about 250,000 with its current FHA programs. Bush also indicated support for a Democratic bill pending in Congress that would temporarily alter tax law to allow homeowners to forego paying taxes on forgiven debt in loans being restructured by financial institutions. This could turn into a nightmare to manage . . . In a previous press conference, Bush opposed helping consumers outright out of foreclosure. “We must show an enormous empathy,” Bush said, but he didn’t think the feds should give financial aid. “If you mean direct grants to homeowners, the answer would be `No, I don’t support that,’” said Bush. Sen. Charles Schumer suggested in a news conference this is a shift for an administration that favors the free market. “The president has gotten out of his ideological straitjacket and seen that in times of crisis, one of the jobs of government is to help,” said Schumer. What else could he do? Sit back and watch the homeless population explode?

The Federal Reserve Bank cut the Fed Funds Rate

from 5.25% to 4.75%. (Fed Funds Rate is the rate banks pay to borrow money) This should be a positive development for credit markets. Additionally, although less noteworthy, they also cut the discount rate (rate at which banks who can’t borrow from other banks can borrow directly from the fed) from 5.75% to 5.25%. - short rates (1 month through 3 years) are slightly lower - long rates (10-30 years) are slightly higher due to expected increase in inflation that will result from the fed stimulating the economy now through a larger than expected rate cut **note that about 37.5bps of the 50bp cut was already priced into the market based on investor expectations going into the announcement. Therefore, rates are only lower about 0.125% (not 50bps). What does this mean for mortgage rates: Short Term: short arms (1/1s, 3/1s, 5/1s) should go down 1/8 in rate (in line with 2yr treasuries) 10/1s and Fixed Rates will be inch’d to 1/8 higher in rate (in line with 10 yr treasuries) Long Term: The real hope/expectation is that banks will start buying loans for portfolio now, providing liquidity to the market. When short term rates were higher than long term rates, it made no sense for banks to borrow overnight to hold 5/1 arms or 30yr fixed rate loans on the books. Now that short rates / borrowing costs are lower, they can make money buying loans. This should provide some support to the jumbo-A market long term. This is all speculation of course. The worsening of the housing market could trump everything (in which case the fed would need to cut more and eventually that will probably happen, the question is when.)

Finally, Some Love for Mortgage Brokers!

In an interview David Bach did with Bankrate.com, he discusses the cost of mortgage refinances. (David Bach is the author of the Automatic Millionaire series of books, and is, not incidentally, a former senior vice president at the Wall Street investment firm Morgan Stanley.) “You have to factor in all the closing costs for a refinance. There is no such thing as a no-cost loan. The loan documents, the HUD-1 settlement statement details it all.” And my favorite: “…There are more good mortgage loan people out there than bad. It’s a very regulated industry.” You can read the full article at http://www.bankrate.com/

Car Dealers Cause Auto Emissions

I read that headline today in an email from Rich Workman, President of the Florida Mortgage Brokers Association.

He goes on to say: Car dealers sell the cars the automakers engineer and manufacture. If it were not for the car dealer then there would be no car emissions. Therefore, it is clear if we simply eliminate the car dealer we can solve global warming. His point being that Mortgage Brokers are taking the hit for the subprime melt-down in the news and from politicians everywhere.

I, for one, am really tired of hearing remarks like these: The Bush administration is pressuring the Department of Housing and Urban Development to speed up the issuance of a Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act proposal to improve good-faith estimate disclosures of mortgage broker fees and settlement costs. Why, when mortgage fees are discussed in the press, and by elected officials, are they always referred to as Broker Fees? It is as if a loan can’t be completed by a Mortgage Banker, or a Mortgage Lender, only a Mortgage Broker. . . and that is not the case.

AND, what brokers make, or lenders make, or mortgage bankers make is already on the Settlement Statement. That’s the law. It isn’t as if we have secret incomes. Whatever we make from the borrower or the lender is on the Settlement Statement.

From the website of Senator Charles Schumer from New York: “Up to 80 percent of subprime loans originated in 2006—the year that lax underwriting seems to have been the most problematic—were adjustable rate mortgages with low “teaser rates” that reset to higher rates that induce payment shock on the borrowers.”

How shocked can they be when they knew it was coming for two years? I have an arm. It adjusted in August. Not only did I know that was going to happen, I got at least ten pieces of mail a week from people trying to refinance my house. And in the last month before it adjusted, the lender called three to four times a day! There was no avoiding the knowledge that my arm would adjust UPWARDS during the month of August. Those high risk, high loan-to-value loans that were generated from the Sub-Prime industry were designed to help people get into homes.

There is not a lender in this country who would just as soon have your house as get the monthly payment. They would all rather get paid than foreclose. I’ve had borrowers who couldn’t qualify for a loan of any kind ask ‘why not? The lender will get the house if I don’t make the payments’ . . . As if in making a loan the lender becomes part of a quiet side agreement to “buy” the house by default.

That’s not how it works. Borrowers who take a two year arm or a three year arm do so based on their plans to sell or refinance in two or three years. In an increasing real estate market, this plan works. BUT, if the property values go down, or even stay the same, there is no refinance to be had, and in a declining market, there is no selling the house to get out of it either.

Paraphrasing Rich Workman again, here: ‘When the real estate market pulled back from a 24-month unsustainable growth spurt, people couldn’t refinance a house that was worth less than the mortgage, and couldn’t make the payment, the Sub-Prime market was left with mortgages that were in default. Then market reacted and the Sub-Prime guidelines got tighter.’

And they got tighter without legislation. They got tighter because the market demanded it. Long before a politician decided to make a to-do about it. AND, 2/28 and 3/27 arms don’t have teaser rates. They are fixed for two years or fixed for three years. After that they adjust, up or down, with caps on how high they can go. I can’t believe that none of the people who got an arm for two years or three years didn’t know that payment was going up. In addition to a loan originator’s verbal disclosure, there are written disclosures at the application process, and at closing, there is a real estate attorney or title company responsible for explaining every document that is signed by the borrower. Arm Riders are separate and distinct documents in the closing package.

If I didn’t understand what I was signing at a closing, I’d ask the guy who was handing me the papers. My pen would hit the paper when I understood what I was signing and I was okay with it. Teaser rates are those 2% payment rates you see advertised that have nothing to do with interest rates. Totally different animal, but people who aren’t in the mortgage business, like politicians don’t know the difference and seemingly don’t care to learn.

FHASecure for Refinancing Adjustable Rate Mortgages in Default

As an FHA lender, we are happy to become part of the solution for the ARMS that are resetting and are in default. In a press release issued by the Federal Housing Administration on Friday, the headline read BUSH ADMINISTRATION TO HELP NEARLY ONE-QUARTER OF A MILLION HOMEOWNERS REFINANCE, KEEP THEIR HOMES The contents are highlighted here: President George W. Bush announced on 8/310/7 that the FHA will help an estimated 240,000 families avoid foreclosure by enhancing its refinancing program effective immediately. Under the new FHASecure plan, FHA will allow families with strong credit histories who had been making timely mortgage payments before their loans reset-but are now in default-to qualify for refinancing… This is huge! Imagine, there were no options a week ago and now there is a refinance, that can include defaults and even go above FHA lending limits. Unprecedented! In many cases homeowners may be permitted to include mortgage payment arrearages into the new loan amount, subject to existing geographical mortgage limits and the loan-to-value limit shown below. Before Friday, only borrowers who were current on their existing loan were allowed to re-finance into an FHA-insured mortgage. Highlights of the FHASecure Initiative
  • The mortgage being refinanced must be a non-FHA ARM that has reset.
  • The mortgagor’s payment history on the non-FHA ARM must show that, prior to the reset of the mortgage, the mortgagor was current in making the monthly mortgage payments.
  • If there is sufficient equity in the home, under additional eligibility instructions provided below, FHA will insure mortgages that include missed mortgage payments.
  • Under certain conditions, FHA will insure first mortgages where (1) the existing note holder writes off the amount of indebtedness that cannot be refinanced into the FHA insured mortgage; or (2), the FHA-approved lender making the new mortgage or the existing note holder may take back a second lien that includes closing costs, arrearages or previous secondary financing.
  • Lenders must determine, as part of the underwriting process, that the reset of the non-FHA ARM monthly payments caused the mortgagor’s inability to make the monthly payments and that the mortgagor has sufficient income and resources to make the new monthly payments under the FHA-insured refinancing mortgage.
Additional Information about the FHASecure Initiative: What May be Included in the FHASecure Mortgage Amount: FHA will permit the inclusion of the existing first lien, any purchase money second mortgage, closing costs, prepaid expenses, discount points, prepayment penalties, and late charges. FHA will also permit arrearages (principal, interest, taxes and insurance) to be added into the new loan amount. Subordinate Financing under the FHASecure Initiative: If the new maximum FHA loan is not enough to pay off the existing first lien, closing costs and arrearages, the lender may execute a second lien at closing to pay the difference. The combined amount of the FHASecure first mortgage and any subordinate lien may exceed the applicable FHA loan-to-value ratio and geographical maximum mortgage amount. If payments on the second are required, they must be included in qualifying the borrower. If payments are deferred, they must be so for no less than 36 months to not be considered in the qualifying ratios. If you have an ARM that has reset and you can’t make the payments, this may be your chance to recover! We’re licensed in Florida, Georgia, Alabama, South Carolina and Tennessee. Send me an email at traci@tracigregory.com and we will see if this will work for you! You may read the entire press release at: http://www.hud.gov/news/release.cfm?content=pr07-123.cfm.